Review by Marty Mapes
The Indian Runner and The Crossing Guard, the first two films Sean Penn directed, received mixed-to-favorable reviews. More importantly, they showed the promise of artistry. In The Pledge, a blue-collar murder mystery, Penn's talent as a director comes into full bloom.

Jack Nicholson stars as a retiring police detective who, on his last day on the job, makes a pledge to personally find the killer of a little girl. Nicholson works hard to keep his promise, following up on every lead, questioning every too-tidy conclusion. The pace of the film follows a conventional mystery, unraveling clues at a slow and steady pace. But the film is also about Nicholson and his obsession, not just with solving a single crime, but with staying useful and relevant after retirement.

Nicholson brings a depth and pathos to the screen that he never has before. Penn brings a sensitive eye and a willingness to try some visually risky photography. On one level, The Pledge is a conventional mystery. But it also transcends convention in every scene. It's unfortunate that critical acclaim didn't translate into ticket sales, but if there is any justice The Pledge will become a favorite on home video.

reviews • videos • recommended • home