Thoughtful reviews, the Boulder film scene

" My kind of trouble doesn’t take vacations. "
— Chuck Norris, Lone Wolf McQuade

MRQE Top Critic

Beauty and the Beast

Diamond edition adds to a top-notch film —Andrea Birgers (DVD review...)

Beauty and the Beast fall for each other

Sponsored links

Advocacy documentaries are on the rise. This year saw the release of Captialism, Food, Inc.and The Cove, just to mention a few. How much you’ll enjoy these movies ends up depending on how sympathetic you already are to the message, although the better the documentary, the less that matters.

The Cove stacks up relatively well by maintaining it focus (unlike Food, Inc.), but loses steam with a collapsing story arc (unlike Pirate for the Sea).

Flipper Flashbacks

Anybody can see the cove, but don't peek around the corner
Anybody can see the cove, but don’t peek around the corner

The title refers to a tiny little fold in a Japanese coastline near a town called Taiji. For half of any given year, passing dolphins are herded toward the shoreline where representatives from Sea World-type entertainment venues gather to select their favorite dolphins — young ones that can easily be tamed and trained. Anybody can watch from the highway or on the rocky path between the road and the shore.

Then, when all of the trainable dolphins are bought and sold, the remaining dolphins are herded around a tall spit of land, where nobody from the shore can see what happens. But Ric O’Barry knows what happens. The undesirable dolphins are slaughtered and sold for meat, in spite of international bans on killing cetacians, in spite of humanitarian mores that frown on killing intelligent mammals, and in spite of dietary common sense (as dolphin meat has high levels of mercury). They are slaughtered even in spite of Ric’s promise to pay the fishermen not to slaughter dolphins — the locals change their tune and say it’s not an issue of money but of “pest control.”

The Cove is part of Ric’s efforts to expose the practice and shut it down. Ric worked on the TV show Flipper for many years and in fact caught 5 wild dolphins and trained them for the show. But he gave it up when he realized how intelligent and social dolphins are. He recounts the story of a captive dolphin “committing suicide” in his arms. Whether or not you accept Ric’s interpretation of the dolphin’s death, it changed his outlook, and he has spent the rest of his life fighting dolphin captivity.

Change Comes From Within

Watching Ric and his A-team of hi-tech commandoes makes for some good, tense entertainment. They make a nighttime raid across razor wire and rocky terrain to plant hidden cameras and microphones, hoping to capture the slaughter on video for the documentary.

But one thought keeps coming back, every time we see Ric and his team confronted by locals. They stand out like a sore thumb. They are tall, white, and European-looking among the homogenously Japanese locals. They are foreigners in a culture that doesn’t welcome them. They come not for commerce or tourism, but to moralize against the local way of life. There aren’t any local activists sympathetic to Ric’s cause. In fact, the locals are so well organized that they make it very difficult for the Westerners to even see the cove.

It’s pretty obvious that no amount of outside pressure is going to spur a change of heart among the residents of Taiji. Until there are local activists willing to shame their neighbors into doing the right thing, no amount of exposure from The Cove is going to effect a real change. Unfortunatley, that makes The Cove less satisfying that it should be.

Noble but Indirect

The best The Cove can do is to make the culturally-independent moral case against the slaughter of dolphins and hope that someone in Taiji will take up the call. If that’s the best the movie can do, then The Cove feels like an exercise in futility. It’s noble, and it’s a step in the right direction, but it’s frustratingly indirect for any westerner moved by its message.

Here’s hoping The Cove ’s Oscar nomination gives it more exposure. Maybe in the long run it will not be so futile after all.

  • T T: The Cove did wiin an Academy Award tonight. But I agree with you that the movie is not totally satisfying, from a Japanese perspective. As a Japanese living in the U.S., I got pretty frustrated watching this film on DVD, and commented on couple other places. You mentioned the need for a "culturally independent moral case". In fact, I was culturally offended by the movie. I felt it takes an hypocritical and arrogant position towards the locals; evidenced in using an intelligence argument to protect the dolphins (what animals - I read pigs are very intelligent - are not slaughtered before our consumption?) and how it portrays the local fishermen as some barbaric people, making mockery of their broken English. All the valid points the movie raises, and there are many, are discredited by that unfortunate attitude of the movie makers. Apparently they will be showing this movie in Japan. Now with the Oscar, it will recieve even more attention from the Japanese, but I think many of the formerly neutral Japanese who see it will leave with decidedly bitter feeling and not exactly encouraged to stop what's going on in Taiji. Thank you. March 7, 2010 reply