" Never trust a woman who whistles for her own cabs "
— Woody Allen, Curse of the Jade Scorpion

MRQE Top Critic

Moulin Rouge

Ambitious, daring, energetic, and entertaining —Marty Mapes (review...)

Everybody comes to the Moulin Rouge

Sponsored links

Even though Superman Returns is far from perfect it’s the best sequel in the troubled Superman series.

Caped Wonder Stuns City

Routh even sounds like Christopher Reeve
Routh even sounds like Christopher Reeve

Superman: The Movie, 28 years later, still ranks as a wonderful piece of cinematic bliss. It’s the quintessential comic book movie unrivaled in giddy heroism until Tobey Maguire donned those Spidey tights a few years back.

One year after Star Wars first appeared, with audiences marveling at that movie’s opening scrawl, Superman topped it with what still rates as one of the most enjoyable and innovative opening credits sequences of all time, this one bolstered by another magnificent score by John Williams.

It was a great, fun movie with an epic scope that treated its main characters with respect while keeping its tongue at least close to its cheek.

Unfortunately, during the subsequent nine years, three sequels would each decline in quality and scale before pooping out with the utterly missable Superman IV: The Quest for Peace in 1987. As part of a DVD box set scheduled for release this fall, a “Richard Donner Cut” of Superman II is expected to finally make its debut; it’ll be interesting to fly it side by side with Richard Lester’s theatrical release, which has not held up well against the test of time.

On the bright side, Bryan Singer’s Superman Returns basically picks up where the first installment left off. There are allusions to Superman II, but there’ll be more about that later. For the most part, the storytelling works best if this is taken as a direct sequel to Superman.

As a companion piece to the original movie, wherein the opening credits took viewers on a trip from Earth to Krypton, this time the credits roll while Singer makes the return trip from Krypton back to Earth. Singer takes full advantage of modern CGI effects to spruce up the visuals, accompanied by John Williams’ rousing march, which in turn has been amped up by John Ottman.

Can You Read My Mind?

At the movie’s start, a title card brings audiences up to date. Astronomers reported finding what they thought were the remnants of Krypton somewhere way out there, so Kal-El (a.k.a. Superman, a.k.a. Clark Kent) left his job at The Daily Planet, somehow built himself a space capsule, and went out there to check on things firsthand.

Picking up five years after his departure (since this is a movie review and not a scientific dissertation, the plausibility of the space travel premise and the time differential will be ignored), Superman (Brandon Routh, most notable for prior work on TV’s Will & Grace and Gilmore Girls) returns to Earth and Perry White (Frank Langella, Good Night, and Good Luck) – seemingly reluctantly – gives ol’ Clark his job back.

The nifty thing is that Singer reboots the Superman story with an entirely different cast (well, aside from Marlon Brando) while keeping its roots in the mythos and style found in the 1978 flick. It’s a smart move because there’s no need to retell the origins story that Richard Donner told so well.

On the other hand, Singer tries to have it both ways. He’s recreated the icy look of Krypton and the Fortress of Solitude, and even brought back Brando, via archival footage, as Jor-El, Kal-El’s father. Also, much like Miss Teschmacher in the original, Singer introduces Kitty Kowalski (Parker Posey, Josie and the Pussycats) as Lex Luthor’s latest ditsy floozy with a good heart.

With all those elements in place, it would be natural to expect a similar tone and demeanor to the 1978 romp. But that’s where Singer changes course, and not always successfully. The tone here is mostly dark and at times too darn serious.

The darker tone in large part comes from Kevin Spacey’s far creepier take on Lex Luthor. Spacey returns to work for Singer, having won an Oscar for his role in Singer’s The Usual Suspects, and together they’ve concocted a more ruthless, psychotic character than Gene Hackman’s wittier, more flamboyant version.

Sure, this Luthor’s well-read and loves opera and classical music, but he’s also a mean-spirited individual with barely a sense of humor who’s traded in his “Park Avenue address” for a fully loaded luxury yacht. After all, this Luthor made his millions by marrying a sickly elderly woman and soaking her estate for all it was worth.

A Good Reporter Doesn’t Get Great Stories…

Along the same lines, the story’s chronology is questionable; Singer seems to be cheating by cherry picking the story threads he wants to follow. Without spoiling anything, if this was a sequel to Superman II, then it would make no sense for Luthor to have to seemingly rediscover the Fortress of Solitude (even as Kitty comments on how he acts like he’s been there before). On the other hand, there is a plot twist involving Lois Lane that most certainly plays off events in the first sequel.

More troubling, though, is that the movie drags on more than one occasion. Its slow start seemed to be intentional, in the name of setting up the storyline, but the film continues to suffer from pacing problems even during scenes of high adventure.

Superman has always been a figure of hope, a character whose first appearance dates back to the Great Depression. Heck, the 1970s were no walk in the park when Supes made his grand splash on the big screen; the movie’s release was wedged between an oil crisis and U.S. hostages in Iran.

That original movie (and even Superman II, for that matter), was an American flag-waving salute to the irrepressible human spirit. Unfortunately, that spirit is lacking here. And that’s precisely what could have sent this new incarnation into the stratosphere, pulling the American psyche out of the post-9/11 muck in the process.

In a beautiful piece of irony, Superman Returns picks up with Lois (Kate Bosworth, Win a Date With Tad Hamilton!) having won the Pulitzer for an article entitled Why the World Doesn’t Need Superman. While Superman learns to fear the wrath of a woman scorned, Lois, eventually, comes to understand the world most certainly does need the Man of Steel. But it’s kind of a bummer realization, not a John Williams-induced epiphany.

… A Good Reporter Makes Them Great

While not all is well in Metropolis, there are still ample reasons to give Superman Returns a healthy recommendation. What it does right it also does right really well.

Routh has big boots to fill and he does so nicely, in a fashion very similar to the quietly dedicated approach Christopher Reeve took to the role. In fact, it’s eerie how much Routh sounds like Reeve.

As Lois Lane, Bosworth is super-cute and convincingly plays an “older woman” who feels jilted by her former super friend. Together, this new coupling of Lois and Superman take the relationship aspect more seriously than has been done in the past; she’s moved on in his absence and she does not greet him with open arms upon his return.

Their relationship provides the bulk of the film’s drama; another round of battles with Lex seems to be provided simply because Singer knows that’s what audiences expect. A really gutsy movie would’ve focused strictly on the romance between the superhero and the journalist.

A lot of fun is also derived from the movie’s look, which follows the same stylebook as the 1978 edition. Here, 1930s American fashion blends in with art nouveau, art deco, and the latest in high technology. (And, even though the movie was filmed in Sydney, it’s made extremely clear the topology of Metropolis is still most definitely that of Manhattan.)

Also, the visual effects are almost uniformly gorgeous; Superman’s flight effects have never been more seamless and Singer does a remarkable job of presenting more of the Superman experience as Supes hovers far above Earth, tuning in to all the myriad distress signals as he picks his next rescue mission.

Singer also maintains a high level of iconic imagery. There’s heavy emphasis on that large red “S” on the (much darker hued) red, blue, and yellow suit when Superman is wheeled into a hospital after a particularly nasty fall.

How Many F’s in Catastrophe?

Providing nostalgia fans with an opportunity to geek out, Superman Returns frequently quotes from the first movie. There’s Superman’s reassurance that flying is still the safest mode of travel and his admonishment that smoking is bad for you. Even Lex quotes Lex on the value of land and the advice his father gave him.

Other bits of good humor include Lois Lane’s continuing challenges with spelling and Jimmy Olsen’s hack photography. A photographer’s in deep doo-doo when a 12-year-old with a cell phone camera manages to take “iconic” black-and-white photos of Superman in action while a supposed pro (or cub pro) with a professional grade digital camera manages only fuzzy shots of Supes flying away.

So, amidst the film’s overly dour tone, Singer still finds room for humor. But there’s plenty of room for just about everything when a film’s run time stretches out past 150 minutes and in that sense Superman Returns shares some of the same bloated, director-gone-wild over indulgence Peter Jackson committed with his remake of King Kong.

Over all, Superman Returns is a solid piece of entertainment that successfully restarts the Superman series. But it’s not an out-of-the-park grand slam like last year’s Batman Begins.

In the grand scheme of things, though, perhaps it’s enough for one movie to simply bring back the Man of Steel and make him a compelling, emotionally complex character. Maybe the next installment will be more fun.

  • tim jensen: Bryan Singer. A talented director who knows how to make a good movie. When I saw his first major film, X-Men, I was impressed. The cast, most notable the senior superstars Patrick Stewart and Ian McKellen, and the talented Hugh Jackman, gave the best performances in the film. I never really was a big Superman fan. I had never read the comics, though I was familiar with the Christopher Reeve films and the 1990s animated series, though I still didn't find Superman cool. When I heard Bryan Singer was doing this movie, I though, 'I can't WAIT to see what he has in store for the Man of Steel!' I finally saw it in theaters, and I was impressed. I was born in 1990, so strangely enough, before 2006's Superman Returns, I had never heard of Kevin Spacey. This was my first introduction to the amzing Kevin Spacey, and I think he was marvelous! To tell the truth, Kevin Spacey's Lex Luthor makes Gene Hackman's Lex look like a wuss! Kevin Spacey creates a crueler, darker, tougher, and a somewhat psychotic Lex who is quiet and, unlike Hackman, doesn't NEED to raise his voice to be tough. Scenes like when Lex tossed his hairpiece to a child told me something: 'Would Gene Hackman do that sort of thing? Not in thise lifetime, dude!' Gene Hackman did Lex for comic relief; Spacey did it with no comedy! This Lex almost reminds me of the evil man Dorian from the Jim Carrey feature "The Mask" mixed with elements of such villians as Anthony Hopkins' Hannibal Lecter and Raul Julia's M. Bison. Now, the Man of Steel! Christopher Reeve was okay as Superman, but he wasn't as good as he was in 1980's "Somewhere in Time." Brandon Routh looks somewhat like Reeve, but I think he makes Superman more than what Reeve was. Routh brings a more realistic approach to Superman, almost completely staying away from Reeve's interpretation of the character. The rest of the cast was good too, much better than the original cast, I believe! Kate Bosworth I believe is THE Lois Lane, and Margot Kidder is sadly now only a m emory. Frank Langella was great as Perry White, turining the character into a more likeable person. Sam Huntington is better at playing Jimmy Olsen than Marc McClure, as he transforms Jimmy into more of a nice person in real life, and he did so well not to define the character as someone that came out of the comics. James Marsden is good as the new love interest as well. Parker Posey brings something the Miss Teschmacher character was lacking: attitude, someone who could criticize Luthor with more attitude. This film does make a minor connection to the first two Reeve pictures (the footage of Marlon Brando and the John Williams theme), but I think it's three times better than the Reeve films. Not quite the emotional spectable Batman Begins was, but it has a pretty dark tone thanks to Academy Award-winner Kevin Spacey! Congratulations Bryan Singer for bringing us another great superhero movie! September 3, 2006 reply