Join the discussion on

" There will be no shooting without my explicit instruction "
— Bruce Greenwood (as Robert F. Kennedy), Thirteen Days

MRQE Top Critic

Creed II

It's all about the importance of character and the ability to face life's challenges. —Matt Anderson (review...)

Creed II

Sponsored links

In The Gatekeepers, six former heads of Shin Bet — Israel’s security agency — go on camera and talk about their work, their country, and their enemies and victims, the Palestinians.

Shalom is one of the Gatekeepers
Shalom is one of the Gatekeepers

The mere subject — interviews with former directors of Israeli intelligence — would be enough to make any documentary worth seeing. As The Gatekeepers tells us, the head of Shin Bet is the organization’s only non-secret member.

But director Dror Moreh doesn’t rest on his scoop. Right from the start his interview subjects are discussing meaty matters. And Moreh doesn’t just settle for talking heads. He uses a technique that joins 3-D models, still photographs, and “handheld camera” to bring photographic documentation to life. Another technique makes the camera seem like a spy searching classified archives in a darkened library. (Ironically, Moreh also presents newsreel footage stretched out of its correct aspect ratio in what looks like a jarring mistake.)

The Gatekeepers makes a solid whole out of a string of anecdotes and analysis that roughly tracks the history of Israel from the Six-Day War in 1967, almost to the present day.

The six men speak frankly about assassinations and torture. You don’t become the head of Shin Bet without being a hawk. Avraham Shalom, the oldest of the interview subjects, left over an incident in which, he says, “we killed a terrorist whose hands were [literally] tied.” Another recalls one of his great successes: assassinating a target using a phone bomb. Another recalls killing between 9 and 14 bystanders, but missing his target, by using a bomb that was too small to break through to the first floor of a building.

There were times I marveled that these well fed, well dressed, father figures weren’t wanted fugitives, given the death and destruction they oversaw. Sometimes it seems as though they only thought of their work in engineering terms, without considering the moral component. Indeed Shalom, at one point sounding defensive, says that there is no morality where terrorism involved. “Find morals in terrorists first.”

Yet later he condemns “overkill” as not only stupid, but immoral. In fact, most of them condemn the injudicious use of Shin Bet by politicians trying to score points. And if immorality isn’t reason enough to rein in an organization like Shin Bet, there are the practical reasons. The phone-bomb assassination stirred a hornet’s nest; relations went from low-level hostility to violent retaliation.

And then there’s the cost of becoming the kind of society that treats an entire class of people so badly. Avi Dichter, the second-most-recent director interviewed, almost (but not quite) compares Israel’s treatment of Palestinians with Germany’s treatment of Jews leading up to World War II.

Yaakov Peri, who led the department from 1988 to 1994, says “I think after retiring from this job you become a bit of a leftist.”