Elsinore could’ve been a much more powerful statement about life and art. Instead, it settles for being merely “good.”
Act 1, Scene 5

Ian (Andrew Scott) with poor Yorick
There is a stunning key element to this movie that’s “based on an idea” inspired by true events. It’s a scene that opens Elsinore and yet it’s too understated and its significance is too downplayed. It’s such a bizarre incident, the first order of business after seeing Elsinore was to confirm this seemingly forgotten chapter in theatre history truly happened.
Back in 1989, 32-year-old Daniel Day-Lewis was starring in a production of Hamlet at the Olivier Theatre, the largest of the three performance spaces at London’s concrete theatrical palace, the National Theatre. After Hamlet sees his father’s ghost, Day-Lewis freezes up. Did he forget his lines? Did he suffer from a severe case of stage fright? One colorful legend has it he saw his own father’s ghost. (His father, Cecil, died when Daniel was only 15.)
Day-Lewis leaves the stage, holes up in his dressing room, and never completes the performance.
Strange.
But true.
The “official” story is Day-Lewis was exhausted by the emotional demands of the production. It’s Shakespeare’s powerhouse, after all, being performed in a challenging theatrical space. More importantly, Day-Lewis never returned to the show based on guidance from his doctor. (Ultimately, he never returned to the stage for any live theatrical performances and instead pursued what became a stellar career in movies, winning three Best Actor Oscars under the direction of Steven Spielberg, Paul Thomas Anderson and Jim Sheridan.)
It’s stunning. Day-Lewis left after 65 performances. And with only seven performances left in the run. The New York Times quoted him as saying, “It conjures up the demons in you.”
The key is Day-Lewis completely bowed out of Hamlet on his doctor’s recommendation. Those demons were too much to fight. It’s a central, significant piece of information that’s somehow not effectively explored in Elsinore. Glossed over. Referenced. Made mention of. But not central enough to the significance of what follows. Instead, Day-Lewis’ exit is shrouded in unnecessary mystery, as if this kid named “Danny” forgot his lines and then became insolent. (Apparently the reviews weren’t all that great, to boot.) And, of course, the movie chooses to fall back on tired jokes about women fawning over the actor whom many deem to be handsome. Especially in tights.
The whole truth – front and center – would have set this drama free.
Because this drama is all about another real actor, 40-year-old Ian Charleson, whose life is being shortened by AIDS.
And yet he wants to step onto that imposing stage in the 1,100-seat Olivier – one in which an actor’s ability to project his voice up to the rafters is a major challenge when physically fit – and perform the title role of Hamlet. And this would be – at least initially – counter to his own doctor’s recommendations to instead enjoy the arts from the seats.
Momenti Di Gloria
Theatre people should know, when you’ve got the drama, you’ve gotta grab it and sell it.
So, the handling of the Daniel Day-Lewis situation is a total whiff here. Inexplicable. Aside from a couple newspaper headlines about Day-Lewis bowing out, the angle is worked less around the toll it can take even on a healthy young actor and more along the lines of the door opening for another actor to step in and replace him. Even if that actor is in fragile health. The demands of the role – regardless of how well-known Shakespeare’s play is – aren’t allowed their time in the floodlights. Instead, it’s understood the play is dark – and long (four hours, but a stagehand jokes about trying to keep it under three). And it deals with heavy topics, including death.
Surely (just as it’s 5:00 somewhere) at any given moment on this earth, somebody somewhere is performing as Hamlet without life endangerment. The man stepping in to portray Ian Charleson, Andrew Scott, has himself tackled the lead role, headlining some 150 performances in London’s West End back in 2017.
As they say, the show must go on.
Setting aside that opening incident, Elsinore (named after Hamlet’s home, Elsinore Castle) is an effective, but perhaps too staid, drama wrapping the AIDS crisis of the late 1980s with the power of art to heal the soul if not the body. And, of course, it’s all accompanied by a Stefan Gregory score that’s occasionally sweeping, to the point of feeling manipulative.
The movie’s marketing tagline is “Live. Gloriously.” It should’ve been a line of dialogue between Ian and his doctor, Margaret Johnson (Olivia Colman). But they do dance around those two words, and it is indeed the central theme within Elsinore, one in which the desire to live a full life now outweighs the damage it might cause later.
Ian Charleson co-starred in Chariots of Fire, alongside Ben Cross. During the first act of Elsinore, 1982’s Oscar winner for Best Picture is turned into a running joke. Everybody knows Vangelis’ Oscar-winning music (which inexplicably even beat out John Williams’ score for Raiders of the Lost Ark), but they recall little else about the 1981 movie. It didn’t send Ian’s movie career into the stratosphere, which was his goal. Instead, he reteamed with director Hugh Hudson on Greystoke: The Legend of Tarzan and he had a handful of other roles, including one in Richard Attenborough’s Gandhi (ironically, in which Daniel Day-Lewis had his first feature film role).
But Hollywood never put Charleson on speed-dial.
Live Gloriously

Margaret (Olivia Colman)
As Elsinore played the film festival circuit, Andrew Scott – who performed beautifully under pressure as James Stagg in the true-life WWII drama Pressure – made waves and spurred on early Oscar talk. His performance is tremendous, no doubt. Scott undergoes several transformations. As Ian the actor enduring AIDS, pneumonia, chemotherapy and grief even as his friends die during the crisis. As Ian the stage presence bringing the exhausting world of Hamlet to life and – yes – projecting his voice for those in the nosebleeds while also taking a different, more understated approach to the character, one that better suits Charleson’s abilities at the time.
It’s certainly an emotional gauntlet.
Balancing the intensity of Scott’s performance is Colman, who brings a soothing but grounded presence as his doctor. This isn’t a cosmetic role by any stretch; Dr. Margaret Johnson was a driving force in research and treatment, setting up the first HIV/AIDS clinic in London. She’s still working in the field as a consultant.
Ian speaks of “The preservation of life. Its glory. Its joy.” And he calmly states, “I’d rather die of Hamlet than AIDS.”
And he pours his all into his performances of Hamlet. (An end title card indicates there were 18 performances; the actual total might’ve been 24.)
It’s all right there. All the dramatic elements. All the emotion. All the profound influences art (music, movies, theatre, painting) can have a person’s life and soul.
And yet somehow Elsinore still feels like it’s missing something at its emotional core and it all ties around that challenge of getting into an actor’s head as he makes that enormous transformation into Hamlet. How is it Day-Lewis felt the need to leave the role for the sake of his own health and well-being? In comparison, how truly reckless was it for Ian to pursue the role with all his might while also staring down his own death?
Maybe those are “unfilmable” concepts.
Regardless, Elsinore makes a good case for living a full life while you have it and that is a message with a value all its own.
