Given all the heartache that’s sown, this Sunrise doesn’t reap enough emotional rewards.
I: The Birthday

Lenore (Whitney Peak) with Haymitch (Joseph Zada)
Sunrise on the Reaping is another back story in the Hunger Games saga. This time, it’s the 50th Hunger Games and it’s Haymitch Abernathy who takes center stage. He’s the rebel, the bad boy who wanted to end the Hunger Games years – decades – before Katniss Everdeen would challenge all the abnormal norms of Panem.
The opening’s both fun, as the younger versions of familiar characters are introduced, and dramatic, as the dangers of this dystopian world’s totalitarian environment quickly escalate, disrupt and erupt.
There’s young Haymitch. Then, Woody Harrelson. Now, Joseph Zada.
Also, there’s Effie Trinket, a contestant advisor and fashionista. Then, Elizabeth Banks. Now, Elle Fanning.
President Coriolanus Snow, the nasty, conniving and contriving autocrat running Panem. Then, Donald Sutherland. Now, Ralph Fiennes. (While unconfirmed, it seems as though there’s a mandate circulating throughout Hollywood that Ralph Fiennes is now contractually obligated to appear in every single film franchise. Surely his turn as Lex Luthor and his introduction as a Jedi knight cannot be far off.)
Caesar Flickerman, creepy games broadcast host. Then, Stanley Tucci. Now, Kieran Culkin.
Plutarch Heavensbee, propaganda strategist and game maker. Then, Philip Seymour Hoffman. Now, Jesse Plemons.
As Young Haymitch Abernathy, Joseph Zada sounds so much like Woody Harrelson, it’s actually a little distracting. Throw in a miniscule, infinitesimal amount of audio syncing issues and it would seem his voice is dubbed by Harrelson. But, movie miracles happen and Zada’s vocal performance here is apparently one of them. Anthony Ippolito transformed into Sylvester Stallone so effectively in I Play Rocky, it’s easy to forget it’s not Stallone on the screen. With Zada, it’s a similar experience here, but there’s also an odd sensation as the physical body and motions don’t always seem to match the vocal inflections, like a singer lip-syncing while performing demanding dance moves.
What’s more disturbing, though, is seeing Drusilla Sickle get rolled out on a hand truck to announce the new tributes for District 12. Her appearance is shocking. It’s part Hannibal Lecter, part Ida Lowry (Katherine Helmond in Terry Gilliam’s brilliant Brazil), following a session of plastic (shrink wrap) surgery. Drusilla is District 12’s advocate back at the capitol. And the kicker is she’s played by the great Glenn Close.
The movie starts with Haymitch finding a new reason to not celebrate his birthday. It ends with the birth of a new hero.
That’s a nice poetic touch. It’s what happens in between that’s a little problematic.
II: The Rascal
“Fun” might not be the right word for either the opening or the ending, given the lethal actions that permeate both. Nonetheless, the conclusion certainly recaptures the attention and it holds some power as it shows the dismantling of Haymitch’s entire world outside of the games, a payback for his resistance to the longstanding system. The ruthless devastation brought down on Haymitch leads to his picking up the bottle, an addiction he’ll carry with him for decades.
The ending offers the expected, setting up Haymitch as a Hunger Games folk hero, but it doesn’t have quite enough punch. Even with some nice cameos to bring home how far and long these stories have now traveled.
What’s troublesome is the lengthy journey between that beginning and that ending. Clocking in at a whopping 158 minutes, midway through Sunrise, things start to bog down and the journey gets overweighted, dragged to a slog’s pace.
The screenplay – based on the 2025 novel by Suzanne Collins – is from Billy Ray and Michael Lesslie, an interesting duo. Ray wrote the screenplay for the first Hunger Games, while Lesslie wrote the previous release, the underrated Songbirds and Snakes (centered on the 10th Hunger Games and telling the back story of teenage Coriolanus Snow). Both screenwriters have loads of great work to their credit, including adaptations of Shakespeare, video games and true-life stories. Director Francis Lawrence is now the go-to guy to helm Hunger Games movies, with this being his fifth out of the six. (Gary Ross directed the first one.)
So, with creatives this entrenched in Hunger lore, why aren’t the odds ever in their favor? Why isn’t there more punch?
III: The Poster

Plutarch (Jesse Plemons) directs the new tribute
To its credit, Sunrise on the Reaping is technically and visually ambitious as the vision and scale of these movies expands. For this one, the scenes in the open-world arena are “filmed for IMAX.” But, even so, there are some unconvincing CGI effects to contend with, including electric butterflies, vicious chipmunks and killer cherries.
There’s a strong theme that’s the movie’s driving force: “Having nothing to lose is a power.” So, for a character like Haymitch, who starts out with so much to lose, including a loving girlfriend, Lenore Dove Baird (Whitney Peak), and a close-knit family, there should be a greater sense of dread, of fate. Instead, there’s the conventional wisdom that a person can’t choose how they live or how they die, but – maybe – they can choose how they live each day. (But not really. Not in the arena. It’s a sentiment that breaks down and ignores Panem’s oppression.)
Part of the problem is beyond Haymitch’s story, there isn’t much else to care about.
These games feature double the number of tributes (48), but that doesn’t equate to double the fun. The games themselves are almost inconsequential, given Haymitch is focused on his own mission to bring the games to an end. That leaves little room for the slew of new characters to make an impact, other than the blows they throw.
Most disappointing is Mckenna Grace’s character, Maysilee Donner. The disappointment has nothing to do with Grace’s performance; Mckenna’s always terrific, whether it’s in Young Sheldon or Ghostbusters or even the challenges of another Colleen Hoover story like Regretting You. The problem is her level of talent is wasted here on a character that doesn’t really go anywhere compelling. Still, she’s made to be a catalyst.
There are others in a similar situation. There’s a brutal bad boy, Panache Barker (Jhaleil Swaby) who certainly lives up to his namesake; he carries on about his own greatness with a certain panache. He’s over the top. There’s also Silka Sharp (Laura Marcus), a tomahawk-throwing threat who could’ve been drawn out as a more interesting and defined character.
But, nonetheless, there is quite a dynamic of manipulation and deviousness that revolves around Haymitch, Coriolanus and Plutarch. They’re the centerpiece. They’re the meat that staves off narrative starvation in this chapter of the Hunger Games.
